Angela Merkel’s attack on “Multikulti” was misjudged? Many believe it wasn’t even tried

Chancellor Angela Merkel congratulating Germany's midfielder Mesut Ozil in the dressing rooms after the Euro 2012 qualifying football match between Germany and Turkey Photo: AFP

Chancellor Angela Merkel congratulating Germany's midfielder Mesut Ozil in the dressing rooms after the Euro 2012 qualifying football match between Germany and Turkey Photo: AFP

The headlines like “Angela Merkel declares the death of German multiculturalism” are all over the internet. One for instance from Telegraph: “Angela Merkel’s attack on “Multikulti” was misjudged: Many believe it wasn’t even tried.”

The failure of a certain ‘multi-kulti’ approach in Germany does not mean the West is wrong to insist on minority inclusion in Southeast Europe, argues Florian Bieber in this article from Balkan Insight. He refers to the German Chancellor, Angela Merkel when on 16 October she declared at a congress of the Young Christian Democrats, that “Multiculturalism is dead”. Actually not to be mislead by certain interpretation here is a literally translated quote:

We are a country that invited guest workers to come to Germany in the 1960s. Now they live among us. For a while we kidded ourselves. We said: They won’t stay, they’ll be gone at some point. But that is not the reality. And most certainly the approach failed to say: We’ll do a multi-kulti thing here; we’ll just live next to and detached from each other and declare how happy we are with each other – this approach has failed, utterly failed. Angela Merkel

Germans are not known for their humor, but they do do irony and sarcasm, says Thomas Kleine-Brockhoff, the Senior Director for Policy Programs at the German Marshall Fund. “Both traits rarely convey in translation. But the video of the speech reveals that Merkel displayed utter sarcasm when she disparaged the “multi-kulti thing” as a hippie vision of peace, love, and brotherhood, as some sort of German adaptation of a multi-ethnic Haight Ashbury,” says expert.

A FEW months ago Germans were basking in the positive glow cast by their multicultural football team, writes The Economist. They did not quite win the World Cup but did pretty well “with a part-Ghanaian defender, a midfielder with Turkish roots and a striker from Poland”. What a great advertisement for a Germany “open to the world”, the Economist goes on. “Now suddenly the talk is of an immigrant-bashing, Islam-hating Germany nostalgic for the firm leadership of the 1940s. Why? And which is the real Germany?”

Chancellor Angela Merkel claimed that Germany’s multiculturalism “utterly failed” but many Germans whose parents came from Turkey complain that they have never really been made welcome, writes Telegraph.

Continue reading


Photos of the Week

source: The Economist

The euro-zone rescue package does not mean common economic government. But the rules are clearly changing..

SINCE 1949, Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty has bound NATO members to a solemn vow: an armed attack on one of the alliance shall be treated as an attack against all. With international markets closed to Greece, and contagion threatening Portugal and Spain, European Union leaders agreed to a similar pledge after a pair of gruelling, late-night meetings on May 7th and 9th.

From now on, they in effect declared, markets betting against one member of the euro zone would meet a swift response from all 16. Emergency finance would be channelled to vulnerable governments from an array of fighting funds of up to €750 billion ($950 billion) variously loaned or guaranteed by EU countries, euro-zone members and the IMF (see article).

The European Union’s policymakers were forced to act with unaccustomed speed and unprecedented force. A promised huge rescue fund and central-bank help for indebted governments have eased the euro area’s crisis. The respite must be used wisely.. (see article)

Electoral defeat at home and the euro-zone rescue package have rocked Angela Merkel’s chancellorship. She now faces some tough decisions..

MAY 9th is not a day Angela Merkel will soon forget. First voters in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW), Germany’s most populous state, booted the chancellor’s allies out of office, meting out her worst political drubbing in more than five years in office. That evening European finance ministers meeting in Brussels armed a financial bomb to deter speculators threatening the stability of the euro (see article). It seemed to work, but may also demolish Germans’ long-term trust in the single currency. Both events will transform Mrs Merkel’s chancellorship. (see article)

Some interesting charts and photos related to the topic: